I had a rest in July 2023. It's very dirty. The beach is not cleaned at all. There's garbage everywhere. A lot of jet skis smell like gasoline because of this.
Much better than in Torangalyk! If you choose between that and that, then Shubar Tubek is better. There are almost no rocks at the bottom. It takes a very long time to go to the depth, good for children. And so, in general, warm water, great weather, a great vacation.